Wyoming's largest department store from 1909 — converted into Sheridan's most singular address.
Wyoming's largest department store from 1909, converted to a private residence in the early 2000s. Four bedrooms, five bathrooms, 9,000 square feet, and one parking space in a private garage in downtown Sheridan — a combination that doesn't exist anywhere else. A forty-foot bar, fireplace, and 98-inch TV, directly across from the WYO Theatre. Luxury that's earned some age.
The scale of the space is the first thing you notice — ceilings that climb above original timber columns, open volumes that feel more like a private club than a vacation rental. The 40-foot bar is fully stocked and operational. The kitchen is chef-caliber. Every bedroom is finished with the same care as the public spaces.
Your stay includes one parking space in a private garage. The front entrance is on Main Street, directly across from the WYO Theatre, with downtown shops and restaurants nearby.
Coffee, dinner, shops and an evening at the WYO.
Explore the downtown guideBuilt in 1909 as Wyoming's largest department store, the New York Store was a landmark of Sheridan commerce for decades. Converted to a private residence in the early 2000s, it keeps the bones of the original structure — the timber framing, the scale, the sense of permanence — while living with every modern comfort. There is nothing else like it in Wyoming.
Sleeps eight across four bedrooms, with one king, two queens and twin loft/bunk sleeping. This second-story home is reached by a large flight of stairs; there is no elevator. Pets are not allowed, and there is no outdoor space. Allure boutique shares a wall with the TV area; the home is otherwise generally quiet. Self check-in. Personally hosted.
Nobody walks in here and plays it cool. The wow happens at the door — every time, without exception. This isn't a vacation rental that happens to be large; it's something else entirely. A 115-year-old department store that became a private residence, that became the most singular place to stay in Wyoming. The 40-foot bar has hosted family reunions, bachelor parties, and corporate retreats — and it never feels like a venue. It feels like yours. Frackelton's is next door; grab the bar high-tops, order the potato gnocchi and a key lime martini, and watch Main Street from the window like you own it.
Verified Airbnb review
Huge, with lots of space to hang out and spend time together — just what we needed and then some. The location is right on Main Street. You can tell the host takes great care and pays attention to details. Lost in history in this rental. It's a must-see and stay. I'm already thinking of who I want to bring back next time.
Verified Airbnb review
The location is incredible and very unique. Worked great for our family of seven adults.
The New York Store Suite
9,000 square feet of Sheridan history.
A question
is a good start.
Booking questions, availability, co-hosting your property — or just wondering if Sheridan's actually as good as we say it is. We respond to everything personally.
Got it. We'll be in touch
before you know it.