The New York Store Suite

The Property

Wyoming's largest department store from 1909 — converted into Sheridan's most singular address.

Wyoming's largest department store from 1909, converted to a private residence in the early 2000s. Four bedrooms, five bathrooms, 9,000 square feet, two-car garage in downtown Sheridan — which doesn't exist anywhere else. Forty-foot bar, fireplace, 98-inch TV, directly across from the WYO Theatre. Luxury that's earned some age. Where John Dutton would stay if he came to town.

The scale of the space is the first thing you notice — ceilings that climb above original timber columns, open volumes that feel more like a private club than a vacation rental. The 40-foot bar is fully stocked and operational. The kitchen is chef-caliber. Every bedroom is finished with the same care as the public spaces.

Two-car private garage on-site — an extraordinary rarity in downtown Sheridan. Directly across the street from the WYO Theatre, steps from King's Saddlery, the Mint Bar, and Main Street's best dining.

The Building

Built in 1909 as Wyoming's largest department store, the New York Store was a landmark of Sheridan commerce for decades. Converted to a private residence in the early 2000s, it retains the bones of the original structure — the timber framing, the scale, the sense of permanence — while living with every modern comfort. There is nothing else like it in Wyoming.

Good to Know

This is Sheridan's premier large-group property. Ideal for family reunions, corporate retreats, wedding parties, or anyone who wants to own downtown Sheridan for a few nights. Self check-in. Personally hosted.