Main Street · Downtown Sheridan, Wyoming

The New York Store Suite

A 9,000-square-foot residence in a former department store, directly across from the WYO Theatre. Four bedrooms, five bathrooms, original timber columns, and a 40-foot bar, with one private garage parking space.

Living room with original timber columns at The New York Store Suite
Guests & bedrooms
8 guests · 4 bedrooms
The home
9,000 sq ft · 5 bathrooms
Pets
No pets
Parking
1 private garage space
The Property

A former department store on Main Street

The New York Store was converted to a private residence in the early 2000s. Its 9,000 square feet include four bedrooms and five bathrooms, with a fireplace, a 98-inch TV, and a 40-foot bar in the living space.

Original timber columns run through the open living areas. The kitchen and bar give your group places to cook, eat, and spend time together, with separate bedrooms when people want to turn in. The bar is fully stocked and operational.

Your stay includes one parking space in a private garage. The front entrance is on Main Street, directly across from the WYO Theatre, with downtown shops and restaurants nearby.

Coffee, dinner, shops and an evening at the WYO.

Explore the downtown guide
The Building

The building’s department-store history is still visible in its timber framing and large open rooms. The Register story below covers the New York Store’s history and its place on Sheridan’s Main Street.

Good to Know

Sleeps eight across four bedrooms, with one king, two queens and twin loft/bunk sleeping. This second-story home is reached by a large flight of stairs; there is no elevator. Pets are not allowed, and there is no outdoor space. Allure boutique shares a wall with the TV area; the home is otherwise generally quiet. Self check-in. Personally hosted.

Around the neighborhood

Frackelton’s is next door, and the WYO Theatre is across the street. We like the high-top seating at Frackelton’s for a meal with a view of Main Street. You can leave the car in the garage for an evening downtown.

Amenities
4 Bedrooms / 5 Bathrooms
9,000 Square Feet
40-Foot Bar
98-Inch TV
Fireplace
Chef's Kitchen
Private Garage · 1 Parking Space
Fiber Internet
Washer / Dryer
Sleeps 8
Downtown Location
Across from WYO Theatre
Main Street Entrance
Personally Hosted
Guest Reviews
Brook Cody, Wyoming · April 2025 · Stayed with kids ★★★★★

Verified Airbnb review

Huge, with lots of space to hang out and spend time together — just what we needed and then some. The location is right on Main Street. You can tell the host takes great care and pays attention to details. Lost in history in this rental. It's a must-see and stay. I'm already thinking of who I want to bring back next time.

Christopher New Lenox, Illinois · August 2025 · Group trip ★★★★★

Verified Airbnb review

The location is incredible and very unique. Worked great for our family of seven adults.

Reserve Your Stay

The New York Store Suite

Explore more stays in Sheridan.

Back to Home View All Properties
Get in Touch

Ask us about this home

Tell us your dates and what you need to know about the suite. We answer personally. You can also call 307.217.6516.

Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email.
Please include a message.

Thank you. Your message has been sent.

The New York Store Suite